What We Make

Pressed, poured, baked — never rushed.

Everything on this menu is made in small batches, starting before sunrise. If it's not fresh today, it doesn't make the list.

Cold-Pressed Juices

Single-origin juices pressed to order. No concentrates, no water added — just fruit, vegetables, and honesty.

Green Tonic — kale, cucumber, celery, ginger, lemon
Sunrise — orange, carrot, turmeric, black pepper
Berry Reset — beet, blueberry, apple, lime
Golden Milk Press — turmeric, oat milk, honey, cinnamon

Smoothies & Blends

Thick, creamy, and made with frozen fruit, plant milks, and superfood add-ins. No ice — ever.

Plum & Almond — dates, banana, almond butter, oat milk
Tropical Storm — mango, pineapple, coconut milk, chia
Protein Rise — peanut butter, cacao, banana, hemp protein
Cherry Recovery — tart cherry, Greek yogurt, honey

Artisan Bakes

Sourdough loaves, buttery laminated pastries, and seasonal tarts — baked from scratch each morning.

Classic Sourdough — 48-hour fermented, crackling crust
Butter Croissant — 72 layers, French butter, flaky gold
Seasonal Fruit Tart — vanilla custard, shortcrust, market fruit
Everything Bagel — house-made blend, boiled then baked

Full menu with prices available in-store

See us on Sullivan St

Interior of Blame The Juice with marble counters and fresh produce displays

Close-up of hands pressing fresh oranges

Our Story

We started because the corner store juice tasted like regret.

In 2014, two friends walked past the same bodega on Sullivan Street every morning, watched the same fluorescent-lit display case, and decided something had to change.

Blame The Juice opened six months later with a used cold-press machine, a secondhand espresso maker, and a sourdough starter named after a song. Twelve years on, we're still pressing to order, still baking at dawn, and still the kind of place where regulars know your name before you do.

Every ingredient is sourced from farms within three hours of the city when possible. Every loaf is fermented long enough to matter. And every glass is poured with the kind of attention you'd give a friend.

Farm-fresh daily

No preservatives

Made with care

From the Shop